5 Worst Ideas for a First Date

Worst first date ideasSome of the most common first date ideas are also some of the weakest, and they can make it very difficult for a guy to land a second date. Here are 5 of the worst ideas for a first date, and what you should do instead. The worst first date ideas are a fancy dinner, a movie, a long event, trying to impress her and splitting the bill. A short activity where you can talk, plus covering the check, works better.

1. Fancy dinner

One of the worst ideas for a first date is also the most common one. It’s the idea that you’ve got to impress a girl by taking her out to an upscale restaurant. This is often a bad idea for a few reasons. First, the fancy dinner is familiar. She’s already been on that date many times, so you start things off looking like every other guy she’s dated. Second, there’s little going on at an upscale restaurant. That adds pressure and makes it harder to keep a stimulating conversation going. Third, committing a whole evening to a woman you barely know makes little sense, since you are still finding out whether you’re a good fit. Finally, if you rarely spend time at formal restaurants, you may feel out of place. You may find it hard to relax and be your authentic self in that environment.

In place of a formal dinner, pick a first date that’s a bit different. Choose something fun that lets you both set aside the pressure of filling every moment with conversation. An activity date, where you take her out to do something fun (go for a hike, wine tasting, ice skating, inviting her over and cooking dinner together) will give her an enjoyable experience in a more relaxed atmosphere. It’ll be something a bit different for her, and give you a better chance to connect on a more personal level.

What actually happens across the dinner table

A fancy dinner puts you across a table from a stranger with nothing to do but talk. You try to force conversation and create chemistry out of thin air. There is always a chance you’ll wind up staring uncomfortably at one another for a good chunk of the night. And if the restaurant is unlike the places you normally visit, that discomfort gets magnified.

Doing something together gives you somewhere else to put your attention. When you shift your focus to an outside activity, conversation can rise on its own. Mini golf is a good example, and so is an improv comedy show. You’re both busy having fun, and talking becomes the easy part.

Keep the plan light

A dinner and a movie is a heavy plan when you’re meeting several new people in a week. It asks a lot of her, and it asks a lot of you, too. A first date is a short check on fit, so scale the plan down to something you can repeat comfortably.

A better idea for a first date is to pick a simple, low-pressure activity. Go for a hike or have a picnic. There are plenty of enjoyable ways to get to know one another when the plan stays relaxed and the focus stays on the two of you.

Spending that adds up

A nice dinner followed by a movie adds up fast, and sometimes more than you planned. That is a big financial commitment when she barely knows you. If you’re dating around and going on several first dates in a week, spending that much on every one may prove unsustainable. A cheaper activity gives you the same chance to get to know one another without setting you back financially. Item 5 below covers picking up the check. When you’re the one covering the bill, choose an activity that is easy to repeat, so taking care of her stays comfortable from one first date to the next.

Make the invitation sound like fun

An activity date is easy to invite her to because it sounds like a good time rather than a big evening out. Something as simple as “Want to check out an improv show this week?” or “I know a great mini golf place, want to go Saturday?” gives her a clear picture of what the date looks like. A short, specific invitation also tells her you’ve thought about it, which sets you apart from the guy who suggests dinner and a movie.

2. A movie

Another one of the worst first date ideas is yet another classic, the movie date. The problem with the movie date (in addition to being yet another first date she’s already been on many times) is that it gives you little chance to talk or connect. You’re left feeling about as close as you were at the beginning of the date, which means she’ll be less likely to say yes to a second date. Plus, the outcome of the date is almost entirely dependent on the movie. If the movie is boring then the date is going to be boring, too.

So when the movie date comes up, take her someplace where you can actually interact. Check out some local live music, or perhaps an improv comedy show. These events will give you that chance to connect and get to know one another while keeping you both entertained.

Why a movie hides whether you have chemistry

The whole point of a first date is to get to know one another and see whether a second date is worth it. How will you determine if there is chemistry and if the two of you are a good fit when you’re both just staring at a screen? Whatever first date idea you land on, make sure you can talk to one another throughout.

The running monologue and the touch barrier

A movie date has another problem. You may wind up with a running monologue in your head: “Should I put my arm around her? Rest my hand on her leg? Hold her hand?” If you feel anxious about what you should be doing, she’s going to pick up on it. That makes her anxious too, and neither of you enjoys the date.

Pick an activity date where you can talk and connect, and the touch barrier gets much easier to break. If she’s receptive, you can work touch into the conversation naturally, touching her briefly on the arm, shoulder, and back as you talk. And that’s exactly how you set up what comes later. When you get comfortable with touch early, it feels more natural to move toward more physical closeness if and when the time comes.

Let the activity carry the conversation

When you’re doing something together, the activity hands you things to talk about. At mini golf you can joke about a bad shot, and at a live music show you can compare notes on the band. Those small, shared moments give the conversation a natural rhythm, and they give you something to build on when you move to the more personal questions further below.

3. Long events

Taking a woman on a date that lasts for hours and hours is often one of the worst ideas for a first date. When you already know her and already have a foundation for a relationship, a longer plan can work. With someone new, keep plans to an hour or two. Why? Because you may find out within 30 minutes that the two of you are a mismatch. If that’s the case, a long event leaves you stuck together waiting for the date to end. Additionally, a date that’s going well can get dragged out to the point where she gets bored and wants to be somewhere else.

So when planning your first date, be sure to keep it short. An hour or two is plenty of time to get to know one another better. If things are going really well, have an idea in mind for how you can continue the date. Bring this option up towards the end of the date and see if she’s interested. Otherwise simply leave on a high note and make plans to see each other again soon.

The time commitment of dinner and a movie

Dinner and a movie asks her to block off most of an evening to spend with you. That’s a lot to ask when the two of you are still strangers, and it may keep her from saying yes to the invitation at all. Even if she does say yes, there’s pressure to keep the whole stretch constantly stimulating, and the last thing you want is her glancing at her watch while she waits for it to end.

Plan to meet for just 60 to 90 minutes. Neither of you has to fill a huge gap of time, and you’re far more likely to leave her wanting more. If the conversation is flowing, you can always offer to extend the date and spend more time together.

Lines for extending a date that is going well

When the date is going well, a light, specific offer keeps things easy for her to accept or decline. You might say, “I’m having a good time. There’s a place around the corner I like, want to grab a coffee?” If she says yes, you’ve turned a short date into a longer one on her terms. If she has to go, you can say, “This was fun, let’s do it again soon,” and leave on a high note. Either way, the date ends while the energy is still good.

4. Trying to impress her

Some of the worst first date mistakes start with mindset, before you pick an activity. For example, guys often believe they need to try and impress a girl when out on the date. Guys should be figuring out whether or not she is right for them.

Consider how much time it takes to win a woman over, only to learn once you get to know her that she’s a different type than you want. So on your dates you may want to adopt more of a “screening” mindset. Keep an eye out for “red flags” and steer clear of a woman who is a poor match for you. By adopting this mindset and letting go of impressing her, you’ll find it’s far easier to relax, feel confident, and form that genuine connection.

What screening looks like on the date

A screening mindset turns the date into a conversation between two people who are both deciding. You notice how she talks about her work, her friends and her free time, and whether the conversation feels easy for both of you. Because you’re curious about her, you stop performing, and that relaxed attention is what helps her relax as well.

5. Splitting the bill

Another common first date mistake is splitting the bill. When you invite her out, cover the check. It’s up to you to take care of her, and picking up the tab shows you’re invested and willing to look out for her. If you split it, she may read it as a friendly outing, and as a sign that your interest is low. After all, friends split tabs. If you treat her the way you would treat a friend, then friendship may be as far as the relationship goes.

Offer to take care of the check and let the evening stay about getting to know her. When the check arrives, a relaxed “I’ve got this one” is all it takes. A simple activity date keeps the bill modest, which makes covering it a habit you can keep up.

What to do instead

Short, low-key plans give you room to talk and connect. Pick an activity you can both enjoy, keep it to an hour or two, take care of the check, and spend the time finding out whether she’s right for you.

Ask questions that tell you who she is

Once you’re talking, the common mistake is firing “interview” style questions at her. Moving from question to question to gather facts about her life makes for a flat conversation. The goal is getting a feel for who she is, because her job and her routine tell only part of that story. So ask questions with a stronger emotional component. You might find out what she does just for fun, what it is about her job she loves, or what she would do with her time if she could spend it any way she wanted.

Curious how to handle the conversation once you’re out there? X-Factor Accelerator (XFA) is The Art of Charm’s program, with a personal starting plan, lifetime training materials and 90 days of weekly group coaching, and it’s where you can work on conversation before the date. Take a look at XFA at join.theartofcharm.com/xfa.

More dating tips

Avoiding the 5 worst ideas for a first date will put you well ahead of some of the other guys out there from the start. To put even more distance between you and those other guys, check out some additional dating tips here.

 

You can debug complex systems at work, but can’t tell if she’s actually interested or just being polite?

You’re not missing confidence—you’re missing the ability to read and respond to attraction signals. Conversation Radar turns your analytical strengths into your biggest dating advantage.