Learned Excellence: Peak Performance Secrets from Navy SEALs | Eric Potterat

Learned Excellence: Peak Performance Secrets from Navy SEALs | Eric Potterat

Learned excellence is the idea that elite performance comes from mental skills anyone can train. Dr. Eric Potterat, a former head clinical and performance psychologist for the Navy SEALs, says those skills are teachable. You can build them with habits like these: choose a mindset for each role you play, focus on process over outcome, build tolerance for adversity in small steps, and spread your life across six pillars.

From the episode published Feb 26, 2024, this guide walks through each habit as Potterat and co-author Alan Eagle describe it on The Art of Charm podcast. Several key moments link to the exact spot where they say it, and each of those links comes with a clip, so you can hear the idea in their own words.

The quotes and linked moments come from one conversation, the episode “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024) on The Art of Charm podcast. You can watch Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on YouTube (Feb 26, 2024). Eagle was working at Google when Potterat gave a talk there, and that talk is where the book began. The practice steps that follow each idea are our own suggestions at Art of Charm, built on what they say. Anything outside the linked moments is our plain-language guidance, and we do not attribute specific words to the guests there.

Use this list to jump straight to the part you need.

Key Takeaways

  • Excellence is learned. The top performers in the book navigated failures behind the scenes and grew by working outside their comfort zone. Read that as an invitation to start your own reps this week.
  • You need different mindsets for different roles. Someone who uses the same mindset for every role is probably performing poorly in the other roles. A competitive, relentless, gritty mindset works on the field and struggles at home with a spouse and children. Be deliberate about changing your mindset for each role you play.
  • Focus on identity. The best performers move from valuing reputation to valuing identity faster than most. When you’re true to your values, your reputation is usually just fine, and time spent worrying about reputation is wasted.
  • Professionals focus on process, amateurs focus on outcome. You have limited control over results and total control over a repeatable, consistent process. Focus on the recipe, and the cake shows up more times than not.
  • Build your beach house on six pillars. The pillars are work, relationships, health, hobbies, spirituality, and legacy. A house resting on many pillars holds up better against the waves of adversity than a house resting on a couple, and a balanced life gives your work a steadier base.

About Dr. Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle

Dr. Eric Potterat spent the last stretch of his Navy career as head clinical and performance psychologist for the Navy SEALs. Over a long career he worked with a very large group of the world’s best performers, and his focus was performance work with strong people who wanted to get even better. What’s really important is that he built his ideas from hands-on practice, so the advice in this guide stays concrete and usable.

Alan Eagle is the co-author of How Google Works and was working at Google when Potterat gave a talk there. The two decided to write Learned Excellence together. This conversation explores how much of the elite-performer toolkit is available to the rest of us, and the short version is nearly all of it.

A good way to use this page is to read one section, pick one practice step, and try it before you move to the next. The ideas build on each other, from values to mindset to process to adversity tolerance, so a single small rep in each area adds up faster than a long list you never open again. Most people read a guide like this, feel motivated for an afternoon, and change nothing. One rep per section keeps the motivation attached to an action.

Choose Your First Rep Before You Keep Reading

Skim the headings above and circle the one that stung a little. That sting usually points at the habit you need first. Write the heading on a sticky note, put the note where you will see it tomorrow morning, and plan to try the first practice step under that heading before the day ends.

Why Excellence Is Open to Everyone

Eric Potterat served as the head clinical and performance psychologist for the Navy SEALs, and his work centered on helping capable people perform even better.

The biggest myth he has run into is that excellence is something you’re born with, and he says it directly in this moment (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:03:08).

“I am so tired… of the narrative of ‘I can never do what he or she is doing because they were born that way.’ It is utter nonsense. I mean, complete noise. In fact, I want the listeners and the readers of the book to run away from that narrative.”

Dr. Eric Potterat on The Art of Charm, “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024)

The clip below starts right before that line, so you can hear the full sentence in context.

The people profiled in the book each tell the same story: every one of them learned their way to the top. The top performers navigated failures that very few people ever saw, and they iterated their growth outside the comfort zone. The takeaway is that excellence can be learned.

Be realistic about the limits. There are clear physical advantages that people are born with, and maybe some intellectual ones too. What to hold onto is that the mental skills that separate elite performers from everyone else are teachable, learnable, and available to anyone willing to do the work.

Performance reaches well past a stage or a playing field. Any time you have an objective and something you care about doing well, you are performing, whether that happens at work, as a partner, or as a parent. Seeing yourself that way is what makes the rest of this useful. The skills below belong to anyone who shows up as a colleague, a friend, a spouse, or a mentor. Most of us have a role or two where we care a great deal and have rarely stopped to ask how to get better at it. That is the opening this episode gives you.

List Where You Already Perform

Write down the places you show up in a normal week: a team meeting, a family dinner, a phone call with a friend, a customer conversation. Next to each, write the objective you have in that moment. Seeing the objective turns an ordinary hour into a performance you can improve, and it gives the rest of this guide a place to land.

Pick One Role to Get Better At

Choose the role where you care most and have practiced least. Ask yourself, “What would a stronger version of me do in this role tomorrow?” Write one small action and do it. A single deliberate rep teaches you more about learned excellence than a week of reading about it.

Catch the Born-That-Way Story When It Shows Up

Listen for the moment you tell yourself that someone else has a natural gift you lack. When it happens, swap it for a question: “What did that person practice that I haven’t?” The question moves you from admiring to learning, and it points at a skill you can train.

Study One Person Up Close

Pick someone whose work you admire and find out how they got good. Read an interview, ask them for coffee, or watch how they prepare. Look for the quiet, repeated habits and the early struggles, because those are the parts of the story that rarely make the highlight reel. Write down one habit you could borrow this week and try it once.

The Default Mindset Problem

Many people carry one default mindset into every role they play. Someone with the same mindset for every role is probably performing poorly in the other roles. A simple sports analogy shows why. Picture a professional athlete whose job is to be competitive, relentless, and gritty. That mindset serves them on the field. Then they go home and bring the same approach to a spouse and children. Potterat asks how that relationship is going to work, and answers himself that it will fall flat (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:05:55).

The clip below starts where Potterat explains the default mindset and then moves into the athlete-at-home analogy.

The fix starts with identifying the key roles you play in life. Your own list might include professional, partner, parent, friend, and teammate. Then you choose words that will help each role perform at its best. Here are three roles to start with.

As a Parent

For a parent, words like empathetic, mentor, guide, and patient work well. Say them out loud before the school run or the bedtime routine. Words that short are easy to recall when the room gets loud, and they give you something to return to when patience runs thin.

As a Professional

Try analytical, decisive, and results-focused for this role. To find your own words, ask what mindset the most successful people in your career have, and how much of it you already have. Pick the traits you’re missing and write them next to the ones you already use. A short, honest gap list gives you a direction for the next quarter.

As a Spouse

Try present, supportive, and understanding here. The athlete example shows why this role needs its own list. The words that win on the field are the wrong ones at the dinner table, so give your partner their own mindset and leave the work one at the door.

You can choose your mindset. Most people just wake up and accept whatever mindset shows up. Elite performers are deliberate about which mindset they’re using and when. This principle applies equally to developing executive presence, where the mindset that works in the boardroom needs adjustment for team building and relationship management.

Eagle calls this one of the revelations of writing the book, and he says it in this moment (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:07:18).

“Wait a minute, I can choose my mindset, because I think most people just sort of wake up, well, here’s my mindset.”

Alan Eagle on The Art of Charm, “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024)

Start the video below to hear Eagle deliver that line about choosing your mindset.

Once you see that the choice is yours, the practice is simple enough to try this week. Be deliberate when you move between roles and keep some sort of process, with markers that trigger your mind to go to the new mindset. These steps make that concrete.

Name the Role You Are Walking Into

Before a meeting, a date, or dinner with family, say the role out loud or write it down: “I’m walking in as a parent,” or “I’m walking in as a colleague.” Naming the role is the first moment you choose your mindset on purpose.

Pick Your Words for That Role

Choose a few words from the lists above, or write your own. For a parent, you might pick “patient” and “guide.” For a professional, you might pick “decisive” and “results-focused.” Keep them short so they come back to you when the day gets busy.

Mark the Transition Between Roles

A small marker helps you switch. Sit in the car for a minute before you go inside, or take a slow breath at the door. Tell yourself, “Work mindset off, partner mindset on.” The marker gives your new mindset a clear starting line.

Notice When One Mindset Is Running Every Room

Catching the default in the act is the skill that makes the rest work. Listen for the moment your voice at dinner sounds like a meeting, or when your partner tells you that you’re in work mode. Treat either one as a cue to pause, name the role you are in, and pick the words that fit it.

Review Your Words Each Night

Before bed, ask which of your chosen words you actually lived out and which one slipped. Write the answer in a single line. After a week you will see which role needs more attention, and you can start the next day with that word at the front of your mind.

Why Your Analytical Mind Is Sabotaging Your Social Life

If you’re analytical, like many engineers and software developers, your problem-solution mindset works well at work. It earns results there, and it makes sense that you lean on it. Understanding that this same mindset comes up short in connection, conversation, and being in the moment is the first step, because it keeps jumping forward and backward and looking for weak points to fix.

When you’re networking, on a first date, or trying to connect with teammates, your analytical mindset hunts for problems to fix, weak points to address, and logical flaws to point out. Connection is built through presence, empathy, and emotional intelligence.

You can learn a different mindset for social situations. Coming up short in one setting shows you the area where you can build a new mindset, one that lets you succeed in networking, connection, and rapid rapport building just as the old one lets you succeed at work. And that’s exactly how equipment works in sport: different sports call for different gear, and different roles call for different mental equipment. This section is our own guidance for analytical readers.

You can be just as successful socially as you are professionally if you’re intentional about switching mindsets when you switch contexts. This understanding is essential for building confidence that translates across different areas of your life.

These steps put the switch into practice.

Swap Problem-Solving for Presence

At your next social event, choose words like “curious,” “present,” and “warm” before you arrive. When you catch yourself hunting for the flaw in someone’s story, return to those words and ask a question about what they enjoy.

Let the Conversation Be the Goal

At a dinner party the conversation itself is the result, so let it be the goal. Treating it that way gives your analytical strengths a break and lets empathy do the work.

Use a Line That Opens the Door

When the instinct to fix something shows up, try a line that invites the other person to share, such as “What got you into that?” or “What’s the best part of it for you?” These questions put your attention on the person, which is the mindset the room is asking for.

Treat a Rough Moment as Practice

Focus on what you can control, which means your attitude, your effort, and your behavior. Apply it socially. Say you go on a first date with someone you wouldn’t normally have picked, and it goes poorly. Your old mindset might tell you the evening was dumb or that you’ll never do that again. Stop and ask what mindset you want, perhaps an optimistic attitude that the next one will go better. Use a rough conversation as a rep for your attitude, effort, and behavior.

Debrief a Conversation in One Minute

After a social event, jot down one thing you did with good attitude, one thing you did with good effort, and one behavior you would repeat. Keep it short and kind to yourself. The habit shows you progress in the skills you control, which keeps you coming back to the next event.

Listen for the Feeling Under the Facts

Engineers and analysts tend to track the content of a story. Try tracking the feeling instead. When someone tells you about their week, reflect the emotion back in a few words, such as “That sounds like it was a lot,” and then stay quiet for a beat. People remember how a conversation felt long after they forget the details, and a pause gives them room to say more.

Identity vs. Reputation

One of the most liberating ideas in Potterat’s work is that the best performers care less about reputation and more about identity. Many of us notice that we worry less about other people’s opinions as the years go by. Potterat’s argument is that the best performers get there faster, moving from valuing reputation to valuing identity sooner than most. He makes the case for identity over reputation in this moment (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:16:52).

“If we know that the best performers in the world are moving away from reputation to identity, then it makes sense… to get people to kind of double and triple down on their identity faster, because you’re literally wasting time worrying about reputation.”

Dr. Eric Potterat on The Art of Charm, “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024)

The clip below begins at the line itself, where Potterat argues for putting identity ahead of reputation.

Values sit at the base of this work, because they describe your identity and let you care less about reputation. Everyone thinks they understand their identity, so the real question is whether you have taken the time to write it down. A values credo is a longer exercise where you document who you are and what you stand for. If you’re true to your identity, your reputation is usually just fine.

Written values also hold up better under pressure. Some people sit on the couch sure they know exactly who they are. That holds while they stay on the couch. Once tension and pressure arrive, they face the reality of a true identity that either comforts them or comes up short against what’s on paper. Writing it down lets you find out where the work is.

The values on your list can stay steady whatever happens. Win or lose, you can still be loyal or adventurous, because values describe actions you can take each and every day in the role you’re performing. Your worth rides on those daily actions, and the scoreboard becomes secondary.

Write the Credo in Your Own Words

Set aside a quiet hour and write sentences that start with “I am someone who…” Keep the ones that still ring true when nobody is watching, and phrase each as an action you can take on any day, win or lose. Those become the backbone of your credo. Read it again a week later and mark any line that sounds like what you think you should say, then rewrite it until it sounds like you.

Test a Decision Against It

The real shift happens when you use your written values as a filter and do the things that are true to who you are, so the noise around you loses its pull. The next time you face a choice, read your credo and ask which option sounds like the person you wrote about. A job offer, an invitation, or a hard conversation all work as test cases.

Separate Your Actions From the Outcome

After a public setback, such as a missed shot, a weak presentation, or a job that went to someone else, write two columns. In the first, list what happened. In the second, list the value-driven actions you took, such as preparing, showing up on time, and treating people well. Reading the second column reminds you that your identity survived the result.

Check Your Credo Under Pressure

A credo earns its keep when the room gets tense. After your next stressful meeting or hard conversation, open your credo and compare it with what you actually did. Mark each line as lived, partly lived, or missed. Lived lines show you where your identity is solid. Missed lines show you where to practice, and finding them on paper in private is far easier than finding them mid-crisis.

Share One Value With Someone You Trust

Read one line of your credo to a friend or partner and ask whether it matches how they see you. If it does, you have a value that shows up in daily behavior. If it doesn’t, you have found a gap worth closing, and a friend’s honest read is a gentle way to find it.

The Process vs. Outcome Mindset

Potterat keeps the process idea simple with a saying the authors come back to often: professionals focus on process, and amateurs focus on outcome. He asks which side of that equation you want to be on, and he puts it in cooking terms in this moment (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:18:13).

“Focus on the recipe, don’t worry about what the cake’s going to look like.”

Dr. Eric Potterat on The Art of Charm, “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024)

This clip begins a few seconds before the cake line so you hear the lead-up and the process-versus-outcome saying that follows.

Everyone answers to someone, whether that’s stakeholders, a team that needs to deliver wins, or the people in your family. You have limited control over outcomes. You can influence them, and where you have total control is a repeatable, consistent process that you exercise. You might execute perfectly and still lose, do everything right and still get rejected, or nail the presentation and still miss the promotion. If you stay true to the recipe, you get that cake more times than not. Outcomes still matter, and the best way to influence them is relentless focus on process.

The other side of the same idea is that sometimes you do everything right and things still go wrong, so stay steady and resist the urge to overhaul everything. That steadiness comes mostly from your confidence in your process and from having a process to adjust your process.

Change One Thing at a Time

Changes need measurement. Think about fly fishing. If catching fish is the goal, there is a short list of things you can change: where on the river you fish, how many casts you make, and the type of fly. If you change all of them and start catching fish, you have no idea why. So make one change, measure it, bounce it off people you trust, and then make another change if necessary. The same trap shows up when you keep stacking golf swing tips from video sites until your process becomes a patchwork that delivers little. The one-change rule works for your routine, your preparation, and your mindset.

Measure How Consistently You Follow Your Process

Pick the steps you control, which are attitude, effort, and behavior. Those cover how you prepare, how much effort you give, and how you respond when something goes sideways. Track whether you did them. A presentation can be a success on process even when the promotion goes to someone else, and that record is what you build on.

Write Your Recipe Before the Big Moment

Before an interview or a hard conversation, list the steps you will carry out however it goes, such as researching the person, arriving early, and asking a couple of good questions. When the moment ends, check the list first and the result second. The list is the part of the performance that belongs to you.

Resist the Urge to Overhaul Everything After One Bad Result

A bad outcome makes it natural to feel that something must change right now. Before you touch anything, ask whether you followed your recipe. If you did, the result may simply be one of those times when you play well and still lose. Write down what you did, wait a day, and then decide on a single adjustment. Your confidence in the process is what keeps one rough result from turning into a full rebuild.

Choose Your Advisors Carefully

Take input about your craft from people who know it. Match each advisor to the question you are asking, and thank friendly coworkers and casual acquaintances for their company while you save the technical questions for people with experience. Before you change your process, bounce the idea off two or three people you trust who understand your field. Ask them, “What would this change fix, and how would we know it worked?” That one question keeps you from building a patchwork process.

Plan the Week Around Reps

On Sunday evening, write the three process steps you most want to repeat in the coming week, such as preparing the night before, asking one question in every meeting, or sending one thank-you note. Put each on the calendar. On Friday, count how many you completed. A week of kept process steps is a better scorecard than a week of results you could not fully control.

The Six-Pillar Beach House and Why Balance Builds Performance

Many of us assume elite performers are obsessed, single-minded, and lopsided. A more useful picture is a life that tends several areas at once, so that whatever you do for a living rests on a wider base.

Potterat uses the metaphor of a beach house. If you imagine yourself as a beach house, homes resting on only a pillar or two are less stable than homes resting on many. As he puts it, “when the waves of adversity, to stick with the metaphor, come, obviously it’s going to wipe out a lot” (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:39:36).

The beach house image comes through best in the clip below, which opens right where he lays out the metaphor.

You can see what that looks like in careers in the military and in professional sport. Some people become so identified with one job title that nothing else is left standing. When it’s time to transition, whether you call it retirement or something else, a lot of those lives fall apart, because they’re so immersed in what they do.

Potterat names the pillars, in order, as work, relationships, health, hobbies, spirituality, and legacy (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:40:36). What’s really important is that a life resting on several pillars keeps standing when one of them takes a hit, and the energy you invest in the others tends to come back to your work.

The clip below opens at the moment Potterat reads off the pillars one by one, so you can follow along with your own list.

Work

Work is the first pillar. Write down how much of your week it takes, so you can compare it with the other five.

Relationships

Friendships, romantic relationships, and family all sit under this one pillar. List one person from each of those groups you want to be in touch with this month.

Health

Health is the third pillar. Physical fitness, nutrition, and mental wellness are good examples to consider. Pick the one that needs attention first and name a small action for it this week.

Hobbies

Hobbies are the fourth pillar. Choose an activity you enjoy purely for itself and put a time for it on your calendar.

Spirituality

The fifth pillar can be religion, and it can also be simple awe at this universe and this planet. Spend a few minutes outside with nothing else to do and notice what moves you.

Legacy

Legacy is the last pillar. Write a sentence about how you want to be remembered and what you want to leave behind, then check this week’s calendar against it.

Take a Quick Inventory of Your Pillars

Write the six names down the side of a page and give each a rough sense of how well it is standing right now. Think about how you’re spending your time and your emotional, physical, and financial resources within each area. The pillar that looks thinnest is where an hour this week does the most good.

Make a Plan for the Pillar You Cannot Reach Right Now

Be realistic. If you’re raising kids in the middle of a career, you may truly lack the time to work out or focus on spirituality. A sensible approach is to be aware when a pillar is undernourished and to have a plan. For example, maybe a few months from now you take a vacation, and during that vacation you go for a long walk every day. Pick your thinnest pillar and write down the date and the action in the same way, so the plan has a place on your calendar.

Reread Your Pillars When Life Changes

The right balance shifts with ages and stages. When you change jobs, welcome a child, move, or face retirement, redo your inventory. A pillar that was thin for good reason last year may be the one that holds you up this year.

Protect One Pillar From Your Busiest Week

When work swells, the quiet pillars are the first to go. Before a busy stretch, choose one pillar and set a small floor for it, such as one call with a friend, one short walk, or one evening for a hobby. Put it on the calendar the same way you would a meeting. A small floor keeps the pillar standing until the pressure eases.

Hold a Weekly Pillar Check

Pick a regular slot, such as Sunday evening, and run down the six names with one question each: “Did I give this pillar any attention this week?” Mark each one with a simple yes or no. After a few weeks, the pattern shows you which pillar keeps getting skipped, and you can schedule a small action for it before the next week fills up.

Adversity Tolerance and How Elites Build It

Top performers tend to practice the habits below more consistently than most people. They build tolerance for adversity on purpose, because by definition the comfort zone is where growth stops.

They build it incrementally, and the key word is incremental. Take on a stretch that is a little larger than what you did last time, and let each rep prepare you for the next one. The techniques below are our own guidance for putting that idea to work, not quotes from the guests. The black boxing moment further down is the one piece that comes straight from the episode, and it links to the exact spot where Potterat describes it.

Pre-Performance Routines

Start with the routines that get you ready to go. Many people use music for this: an energetic song can set a very different mindset than a calm piece, and calmer music suits the wind-down afterward. Your morning is a routine already. If you look at it as the process you use to get ready for the day, you can change it to put yourself in the best state to perform. Try choosing one song or one small ritual and using it before every important moment, so your body learns the cue.

Visualization With Contingencies, or Rehearsing the Plan B

Mental rehearsal includes things going wrong. Picture the moment, picture the obstacle, and practice your response. A cheat sheet, or a joke ready to go if you lose your place, is the simple version. The section on contingency planning below walks through how that works.

Positive Self-Talk

Positive self-talk and thought management during the performance belong on the list. Choose one sentence that works for you in a pressure moment, such as “I’ve prepared for this,” so the voice in your head is on your side.

Black Boxing, or Closing the Door on the Last Mistake

Black boxing is the habit of sealing a mistake away so it stays out of the next moment. The psychological term for it is compartmentalize. Here is how Potterat opens the idea (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:30:47).

“When things don’t go well, and by the way we’re human and we interact with technology, there are going to be failures all the time.”

Dr. Eric Potterat on The Art of Charm, “Eric Potterat and Alan Eagle on Learned Excellence” (Feb 26, 2024)

The clip below begins as Potterat introduces black boxing and runs into his Van Halen concert story.

He then tells a story from a Van Halen concert he attended with his wife. David Lee Roth forgot the lyrics in the middle of a song, swore, and turned to the band to start again from the top. Potterat’s point is that you have to be able to compartmentalize, to black box the mistake, so it stays out of the rest of the concert, or the other innings and quarters an athlete is going to play. Without a way to box a mistake, one stumble can freeze everything that follows. Later, away from the performance, you open the box and run an after action review. A simple way to practice: when you stumble in a meeting, say a short phrase to yourself, such as “boxed, next point,” and keep going.

Breathing as a Physical Tool for the Stress Response

Breathing sits alongside visualization, black boxing, contingency planning, and positive self-talk as a tool worth practicing. Pair a slow breath with your pre-performance routine so you have a physical way to manage stress before you begin.

Post-Performance Routines

Calm music or a quiet walk can serve as a post-performance routine. The same intentionality applies to downtime. If you love your couch time in the evening, put it on your calendar and keep that time for rest alone. A routine at the end of the effort helps you decompress and carry fresh energy into the next role.

These skills are all learned, and everyone starts from the same place with each one. These same principles apply to influence and persuasion, where managing your own state under pressure directly affects your ability to lead and connect with others.

Audit Your Morning as a Routine

Every morning already has a process, even if it is pajamas, coffee, and a shower. Write down what you do from the moment you wake up until you start your first task. Next to each step, note whether it moves you toward the state you want or away from it. Change one step, such as moving your phone out of reach or adding a few minutes of quiet, and watch how the day feels. The point is to be a little more intentional about time you already spend.

Build a Starter Routine This Week

Pick one technique from the list, such as a pre-performance song, and use it before three different moments this week. Write one line after each about how you felt walking in. If it helped, add a second technique next week, because changing one thing at a time lets you see what works.

Pick the Smallest Stretch You Can Do Today

List a few things just outside your comfort zone, then circle the smallest one. It might be asking a question in a group, sending a message you have been putting off, or introducing yourself to one new person. Do it today, note how it went in a sentence, and choose a slightly larger one for next week. Small, steady stretches build tolerance without the crash that comes from leaping too far.

Find Your Wind-Down Ritual

After a demanding day or a big event, give yourself a short, repeatable way to shift gears: a walk around the block, a cup of tea, or a few minutes of quiet music. Use the same ritual each time so your mind learns that the effort is over. A reliable wind-down protects your energy for the next role you step into.

The Power of Controlled Failure

Small, deliberate failures build resilience. Controlled failure means choosing a stretch that is real enough to teach you something and small enough to recover from. Kids benefit from this approach, and so do adults.

Incremental risk is worth practicing because the world keeps changing, and the ability to adapt to adversity is a skill you will use for the rest of your life. Each small stretch gives you evidence that you can handle discomfort and keep going.

Many people avoid risk because they view failure as a threat to their reputation. When you shift to an identity-based mindset, failure becomes data you can use and input you can act on. Think about the most significant learnings of your own life, and you will likely find that many of them came from setbacks.

Here is a short checklist built on the incremental-risk idea, with each move small and repeatable.

Start Small

Choose low-stakes situations to practice. Speaking up once in a meeting or starting a conversation with a stranger at an event are the kind of reps that fit. When you take on a pile of changes at once, one stumble can tempt you to abandon the rest, so choose one stretch at a time.

Focus on Learning

Ask what this taught you. After each small stretch, write one sentence about what you learned. That one sentence is the return on the discomfort.

Iterate Gradually

Increase difficulty slowly over time. If you spoke up once in a meeting, speak up twice next week. If you started a conversation with one stranger, aim for a longer one next time.

Measure Progress

Track your growing comfort with discomfort. A short log of what you tried and how it went shows you the trend, which is more reliable than your memory of the worst day.

Reframe the Sting

When a small attempt goes badly, try saying, “That was a rep, and here is what it showed me.” The line takes the heat out of the moment and points your attention at the lesson. Then pick the next rep and put it on your calendar.

Pair Each Stretch With a Plan B

Before you try something new, write one sentence about what you will do if it goes sideways, such as “If I freeze, I’ll ask a question.” Having the line ready makes the stretch safer, and a safer stretch is easier to repeat. Over time the plan becomes a habit that travels with you into bigger challenges.

Contingency Planning Without Catastrophizing

Preparation is a sensible response to the fact that things go wrong, and being ready makes you a realist. Eagle makes that case in this moment, and his example is easy to picture (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:25:53). Take a presentation where your laptop decides it’s the moment to reboot and install an update, and now you have a lot of time to fill. Be ready with a second laptop or a whiteboard.

The clip below opens on Eagle’s answer about why preparing is different from catastrophizing, starting with the laptop example.

Now picture yourself most of the way through a talk you practiced, and your mind goes blank. With no contingency planned, you get several seconds of stammering on stage in front of an awkward audience. With a plan, you glance at a cheat sheet, or you have a joke ready to go, because simple things like that reduce stress.

Our guidance here is simple: plan for more than one thing going wrong, and write each backup down before the moment arrives. The habit is open to anyone. You can be ready for the unexpected whether or not you work as an astronaut, surgeon, or Navy SEAL.

Think in layers. When the first option falls through, a second and a third are already waiting, and the moment passes as a minor event. A contingency plan lowers the stress response and keeps you from catastrophizing, because you know what you will do.

The same idea extends to visualization. Build contingency planning into it. If you only rehearse a smooth delivery from start to finish, the first surprise catches you cold. Bake the problems into the rehearsal, because that reduces stress, since you know that no matter what happens you’re ready.

These three steps turn the idea into a habit.

Write Your Plan B in One Sentence

Before a presentation, a tough conversation, or a networking event, finish the sentence “If this goes sideways, I will…” with something small and specific. A glance at your notes, a pause and a sip of water, or a light line you have ready are all fair answers.

Have a Plan C Ready Too

Think in layers. When the first two options fall through, a third is already waiting, and the moment passes without a spike of stress. Write the second and third option next to the first, and you have the full set. Keep the list somewhere you will see it before you walk in, such as the top of your notes.

Rehearse the Stumble Out Loud

Practice your talk once while deliberately losing your place. Pause, glance at your cheat sheet, and say a recovery line such as, “Let me come back to that point in a second.” Doing it once in private makes the real moment feel familiar, and familiar moments carry less stress.

After Action Reviews for Success and Failure

The military uses a practice called after action reviews, or AARs, and Eagle brings it up through the Miami Heat coach Erik Spoelstra in this moment (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:34:15). Any listener can borrow it. You box the mistake in the moment to stay mission-minded, and then later, in a safer space away from the performance, you unpack it with people who can give you honest input.

The clip below starts as Eagle introduces the term after action review and the coach who borrowed it from the military.

Many performers lean on a team of coaches and advisors. In business, a professional coach can play the same role. Whoever it is, you need someone who helps you ask what you’re learning.

A simple set of three questions, which are our suggestion, makes the review practical.

What Did We Do Well?

What worked and should be repeated?

What Can We Do Better?

What failed or could be improved, and what did you have to black box?

What Processes Can We Put in Place to Improve Next Time?

How do we systematize the learning? If you lost your place on stage, the process might be a cheat sheet or a joke, so the same failure stays in the past.

The key is creating emotional distance. After a mistake you can feel mad, upset, sad, and down on yourself, and you’re still too close to open the box. A good rule of thumb is to wait until the emotions settle, often a day or two after the game, the interview, or the presentation, then gather the people involved and unpack the box together. With the emotions lower, there is less opportunity for finger pointing, and the group can be much more rational.

Patience matters here. The end of any big effort is full of highs and emotions, and a good review creates the space for those emotions to dissipate first. Emotions spread between people, and decisions made out of emotion tend to be poor ones. Success teaches more once you look past the high.

After important presentations, job interviews, difficult conversations, or any significant performance, take time to analyze what happened. What you learn becomes part of your process for next time. These steps help you run the review well.

Put the Review on the Calendar

Right after a big moment, put a short block on your calendar a couple of days out and label it with the event. When the time arrives, answer the three questions in writing. Having it scheduled means the learning happens even when the week gets busy.

Check Your Emotional Temperature First

Before you open the box, rate how you feel on a simple scale from calm to charged. If you are still riding a high or stewing in frustration, wait another day. When you sit down, aim to be emotionally neutral, so you stay level whether you lean toward blame or toward celebration. A neutral review gives you information you can use.

Review the Wins Too

Success teaches more when you look past the emotional high. When something goes well, run the same three questions so you can name what worked and repeat it on purpose.

Invite One Honest Voice

Choose one person who will give you honest input and ask them to join your review. A good opener is, “I’m reviewing how that went. Would you tell me what you saw?” Thank them for whatever they say, and write it down before you respond, so you collect the information first and judge it later.

How to Raise Resilient Kids

If you’re a parent, Potterat offers a short list of things to do with your kids that he would count as a strong victory, and he lays it out in this moment (Potterat on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:47:19). The three questions below are our plain-language summary of that advice. Ask them every day.

The clip below opens as Potterat begins his list of daily questions for parents.

Ask What They Learned New Today

This pushes them to try something new and adopt a new skill.

Ask Whether They Were Brave

This encourages them to work incrementally outside a comfort zone.

Ask Whether They Were Kind

Kindness and empathy strengthen a child’s resilience. The question builds empathy and emotional intelligence.

If you focus on those three things, over time the effect compounds like interest.

Kids can also learn the tools in this guide: breathing, visualization, black boxing, contingency planning, and positive self-talk. If we ask them to work through discomfort, it helps to hand them tools to do it with, and parents and mentors can teach those tools at home.

Small pushes work well, and Eagle shares a story with exactly this shape (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:45:40). A former Navy SEAL went to Hawaii with his mom as a boy, saw people diving into a lagoon, and asked his mom to go talk to them so he could join. She told him to go talk to them himself. He said that was scarier than diving off the cliff, and he remembers it as a watershed moment. Notice that she was right there and sent him into no real danger, since the push was small and the setting safe. You can borrow the same pattern at the park, at a party, or on a family outing. When your child spots a group doing something that looks fun, hand the first step back to them, stay close by, and let your child walk over and ask. Afterward, ask how it felt before and after, so the small win gets noticed.

The clip below starts the Hawaii story from its first line, right as Eagle sets up the scene.

The message for parents is to let kids work through manageable adversity on their own. Give them tools and let them practice using them. These steps put that into daily life.

Make It a Dinner Table Habit

Ask the three questions at the same time every day, such as at dinner or at bedtime. A steady rhythm turns them into a ritual, and the answers give you a small window into how your child is stretching.

Let Them Take the Social Risk Themselves

When your child wants to try something new, such as joining a group of kids already playing, let them make the introduction. Offer a first line they can use, such as “Can I play too?” and let them walk over. The small social fear they face on their own is the repetition that builds courage.

Let Boredom Do Some of the Work

Boredom is a gentle kind of adversity for a child. Send them outside to entertain themselves and occupy their time for a good stretch. Once a child figures that out, they plug into their imagination, their resourcefulness, and their social skills, which will help them in the wider world.

Answer Their Answers

When your child answers the three questions, respond with curiosity. Try, “Tell me more about the brave part,” or “What made that kind?” Your interest shows them the answers matter, and the conversation teaches them to notice their own growth.

Model the Stretch Yourself

Kids learn a lot from watching you. Once a week, tell your child about one small thing you tried that felt uncomfortable and what you learned from it. Hearing you describe a rough attempt and a calm recovery shows them that stretching is a normal part of life.

When to Pivot vs. When to Persist

One of the hardest decisions any performer faces is when to keep pushing through adversity and when to change direction. A useful reframe is to say pivot instead of quit. Let your values be the compass, and ask whether a new path still lets you act on them. If a career as a pro athlete or musician closes, ask how you can find another outlet for that competitiveness and pivot there.

Eagle’s example is Derek Walker, now a finance executive at Nike, and he begins the story in this moment (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:49:20).

The clip below starts as Eagle introduces Derek Walker and the baseball career that ended before it reached the majors.

Derek wanted to be a pro baseball player and spent several years in the Diamondbacks organization before that dream ended. He asked what he liked about that experience, what he learned from it, and where he could get a similar experience, so he went for the Navy SEALs. He made it almost all the way through training, through Hell Week, and failed. He asked what he could learn from that, went into business, got an MBA, and has done very well. Reframing a failure from quitting to pivoting was very powerful for him.

A good pivot starts with better questions about the experience you’re leaving behind. What did I like about it? What did I learn? Where can I get a similar experience? Those questions turn an ending into a next step.

The checklist below is ours, built on the compass idea, and the questions help you decide whether to pivot.

Values Alignment

Does this still align with who I am? Look at your written credo and see whether the role or goal still fits it.

Growth Opportunity

Am I still learning and developing? A plateau that lasts long enough is worth examining.

Passion Sustainability

Can I maintain enthusiasm for the process? Look at the daily work, along with the result you hope for.

Alternative Paths

Are there other ways to find the same satisfaction? Derek kept his competitive drive and found a new arena for it.

Sometimes the competitive drive that made you want to be a pro athlete can be redirected into business. Sometimes the precision that made you want to be a surgeon can be applied to engineering. The values remain, and the application changes.

Name the Itch You Want to Scratch

Finish the sentence, “What I loved about this was…” with three honest answers, such as competition, craft, or teamwork. Then list two places where you could get that same sense of satisfaction. The list shows you that the thing you love can travel with you, which is the heart of a pivot.

Test the Pivot Small

Before you change direction for good, try the new path in a low-stakes way. Take a short project, shadow someone, or volunteer for a task in the new area. Notice whether the work gives you the same spark. A small test gives you real information and keeps the pivot from being a leap in the dark.

Leadership Performance Under Pressure

Leaders carry their own state into every room, so the skills above matter most when other people are watching you. Emotions spread: around an anxious person you tend to become more anxious, and around people who are angry and irritated you pick up the same edge. When giving or receiving input, aim to stay emotionally neutral so you are steady either way.

The after action review shows process focus and emotional distance at work in a leader’s calendar. The team review waits until emotions subside, so the conversation stays rational. If you lead people, try the same move: before you give input after a tough result, check your own state, and wait until you can be emotionally neutral.

Whether you’re leading a military unit, a corporate team, or a family through a hard stretch, the same pieces carry over: keep your attention on process, keep more than one pillar standing, and build adversity tolerance one step at a time. That last line is our own reading of the episode.

Take a Breath Before You Respond

When a team member brings you bad news, take one slow breath and ask a question before you offer an opinion, such as, “Walk me through what happened.” The pause lets your own state settle, and your calm sets the tone for everyone else in the room.

Wait for Neutral Before You Give Input

If a result has you frustrated, hold your input until the next day. Write down what you want to say, reread it once your temper has cooled, and keep only the parts that help the person improve. Decisions made from calm tend to hold up better than decisions made in the heat of the moment.

Name the Role You Are Playing as the Leader

Before a hard team conversation, pick the words that fit the leader you want to be in that room, such as steady, curious, and clear. Write them at the top of your notes. When the discussion heats up, glance at them and ask yourself which word the moment calls for. A leader with chosen words has something to hold onto when everyone else is reacting.

What the Learned Excellence Book Covers

The book is organized into disciplines, more or less in order, and Eagle walks through that order in this moment (Eagle on The Art of Charm (Feb 26, 2024), 00:20:33). It starts with values as the foundation: who you are and why you’re performing. A whole chapter covers mindset, then process, and then adversity tolerance. That order matches the thesis running through this whole conversation: if we are all performers, then we can all train like one.

The clip below starts as Eagle lays out the order of the disciplines, beginning with values.

Read the Book in Order

Because the disciplines build on one another, start with values and give each chapter a week before you move on. Write one action from each chapter on an index card and keep the cards where you will see them. By the time you reach the later chapters, you will already have practice behind you.

Turn Your Own Plan Into Calendar Entries

As you finish each chapter, copy your next step onto your calendar with a date and a single first action. A plan with a date and a first move tends to get done. Review the calendar entries at the end of each week and adjust the next one based on what you learned.

Teach One Idea to Someone Else

After each chapter, explain one idea to a friend, partner, or coworker in a couple of sentences. Teaching forces you to find your own words, and the questions you get back show you what you understand and what needs another pass. It also gives the other person a chance to try the idea alongside you.

Building Your Performance Operating System

Learned excellence is systematic, and anyone can apply it. Write down your roles, pick a few words for each, and review a hard conversation a couple of days later with three questions. Begin this week by writing your roles on one sheet of paper and choosing a word or two for the first role you step into tomorrow.

Start with these fundamentals. They are our own guidance, built on the ideas above.

1. Values Clarification

Everything else rests on knowing who you are, so begin here.

  • Write down your core values and create a personal credo
  • Make decisions from your identity
  • Use your values as a filter for opportunities and choices

2. Mindset Management

Each role you play asks for its own mindset, and you get to pick it.

  • Identify the key roles in your life
  • Choose specific mindset words for each role
  • Create transition markers when moving between roles

3. Process Focus

Put your attention on the part of the performance you control.

  • Define your preparation and execution routines
  • Focus on what you control, which is attitude, effort, and behavior
  • Measure how consistently you follow your process

4. Adversity Tolerance

Grow your capacity in small steps so setbacks stay small.

  • Incrementally expand your comfort zone
  • Build contingency plans for likely scenarios
  • Practice black boxing mistakes during performance

5. Recovery and Balance

Sustained performance needs a life with more than one pillar and a habit of learning from each effort.

  • Invest in all six pillars, which are work, relationships, health, hobbies, spirituality, and legacy
  • Create pre and post-performance routines
  • Build regular after-action reviews into your practice

Your First Week, Day by Day

Here is a simple way to start. These steps are our own suggestion, so adjust them to your schedule.

  • Day one: List your roles and circle the one that matters most right now.
  • Day two: Pick a few words for that role and say them before you walk in.
  • Day three: Write the first lines of your credo and keep the ones that ring true.
  • Day four: Write the recipe for one upcoming moment and check it afterward.
  • Day five: Take one small stretch outside your comfort zone and log how it went.
  • Day six: Write a one-sentence Plan B for your next big conversation.
  • Day seven: Run a short review with the three questions and choose next week’s single change.

Excellence is a method you can learn. In our view at Art of Charm, the same habits can carry into job interviews, difficult conversations, creative projects, and leadership challenges, and that is our own take, separate from the episode. We also see this systematic approach supporting personal magnetism and likeability, since showing up with steady confidence and real preparation tends to draw people toward you. That is also our view, and it is yours to test.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can anyone really learn to perform at an elite level?

Yes. While some people are born with physical advantages, the mental skills that separate elite performers are learnable. Potterat says excellence can be learned and that the top performers grew by working outside their comfort zones. The skills are mindset management, process focus, and adversity tolerance, and you can start practicing each one in small steps this week.

How do I know which mindset to use in different situations?

Start by identifying the key roles you play (parent, professional, friend, etc.). For each role, write down a few words that describe the mindset needed to excel. For a parent, words like empathetic, mentor, guide, and patient work well. As a professional, you might need to be decisive, analytical, and results-focused. Practice transitioning between these mindsets deliberately, using a small marker such as a breath at the door.

What’s the difference between focusing on process vs. outcome?

You have limited control over outcomes and total control over your process. Professionals focus on preparation, effort, and execution, the recipe, and let results follow. When you consistently execute good process, good outcomes follow more often than not. Focusing on outcomes that sit partly outside your control creates anxiety and inconsistent performance.

How can I build adversity tolerance without traumatizing myself?

Start incrementally with small challenges. Practice small discomforts first, such as having difficult conversations, trying new activities, or speaking up in meetings. Build your tolerance gradually over time through controlled exposure to manageable adversity, with situations that stay within reach of your comfort zone.

Why is balance important for high performance?

A life resting on several pillars is more stable than a life resting on one or two, and the energy you invest in other areas supports your work. Think of life like a beach house, where homes on many pillars hold up better when the waves arrive. The six pillars are work, relationships, health, hobbies, spirituality, and legacy.

Where should I start if I only have a few minutes a day?

Start with one role and one word. Each morning, name the role you will step into first and pick a single word for it. At night, note whether you lived that word out. This takes a couple of minutes, and after a week you will have a clear picture of which role needs more attention.

Who is Dr. Eric Potterat?

He’s a performance psychologist who spent his career in the U.S. Navy, including his last stretch as head clinical and performance psychologist for the Navy SEALs. Over that career he worked with a very large group of high performers. He co-wrote Learned Excellence with Alan Eagle.

Who is Alan Eagle?

Alan Eagle is the co-author of How Google Works. He was working at Google when Eric Potterat gave a talk there, and the two decided to write Learned Excellence together.

What is Eric Potterat’s Learned Excellence book about?

The book is organized into disciplines, starting with values and then moving through mindset, process, and adversity tolerance. The ideas apply well beyond sport and the military, and you can use them in your work, your family, and your friendships.

What does Eric Potterat speak about?

On this episode he covers choosing a mindset for each role you play, focusing on identity over reputation, and trusting process over outcome. He also talks about contingency planning, black boxing mistakes, and keeping a balanced life. He gave the Google talk that first connected him with Eagle.

Curious where your performance skills stand? Try the Influence Index Quiz (learn where your performance skills stand and get personalized recommendations for improvement). The Influence Index is a short quiz that scores your skills at reading the signals, reading the room, choosing the moment, making it clear, and following through. Curious how these habits work inside a full system? The X-Factor Accelerator is our coached program for social skills, confidence, presence, and connection, with an onboarding call and weekly group coaching, so you can practice the habits in this guide alongside a coach and a group. Take a look at the X-Factor Accelerator.

Get the Best of the Best

With over 800 podcast episodes, it’s hard to know where to start.
Let’ us help.

You may also want to listen...